Fire of Spring
...so you're after the road to Samarkand
Control (2007) 
17th-Jun-2007 02:28 am
gt_anne.smoking


Anton Corbijn's film about the life, marriage, struggles, and eventual suicide of Joy Division lead singer Ian Curtis, Control, screened in Sydney tonight (well, last night) as part of the Sydney Film Festival at Dendy Opera Quays.

Dae and I were in the back row, left corner. (I won't give you the whole story on why we got in so late, except to say that there were pancakes involved, and a lot of rain. As a result, I was sitting next to a woman who nodded her head and shook all the seats irritatingly with her body's movement every time a song came on - which was often. A mixed blessing.

The film reels had come from Cannes, where it had been showing at the film festival last month. The SFF organisers, upon opening the mailed package yesterday, had discovered that out of the four reels of the film, the third one was missing. Being all the way Down Under, there was no possibility of getting it flown in on time for the screening. But no panic! the festival representative told us as she introduced the film. A digital copy would be played in place of the missing reel, and while it was in a different aspect ratio and the transition was not precisely seamless, it wasn't such a huge distraction that it took much away from my experience of the film. Notice I didn't say 'enjoyment'. That would be too simplistic a word.)

Sam Riley is excellent in the pivotal role of Ian Curtis, and Samantha Morton plays his wife, Deborah Curtis. The cast also includes Craig Parkinson (as Tony Wilson) and Toby Kebbell (as Joy Division's manager, Rob Gretton); and portraying the other band members of Joy Division are Joe Anderson (as Peter Hook), Harry Treadaway (as Stephen Morris) and James Anthony Pearson (as Bernard Sumner).

Before going any further, I have to confess that what little I knew of Joy Division - the Manchester post-punk band that would, after Curtis' death, be renamed New Order - came mostly from watching Michael Winterbottom's 24 Hour Party People (2002). It was a wild, ironical, and very funny film centred on Tony Wilson and his legendary record label, Factory Records, which signed up the band. (Sam Reily, I've just discovered, actually had a role in 24 Hour Party People. He played The Fall's lead singer, Mark. E. Smith.) I enjoyed Winterbottom's film on its own quirky merits, but I also know music lovers far more knowledgeable than myself who disliked its irreverant portrayal of the Manchester scene of the late-1970s and early-1980s that would become so influential on music in the decades following.

In the first quarter of both Control and 24 Hour Party People, we see the same event that reputedly started it all: the Sex Pistols show at the Manchester Lesser Free Trade Hall on July 20, 1976. Tony Wilson and all the members of the future Joy Division, along with Deborah Curtis, were among those who attended the show and it left them - we are all aware - forever changed.

But what came before and, more crucially, after that scene in the two films is very different.



Control is filmed entirely in black and white, and the very last word anyone could use to describe it would be "irreverant". The camera is minutely sensitive and empathetic to Curtis' inner emotional landscape and makes every moment he's on screen - from the intimate, private scenes of Curtis alone in his room writing lyrics or listening to music, to the gigs where he stands alone and isolated above the audience pit - quietly, often excrutiatingly beautiful to watch.

But if this is a rather bleak film (and it is), the actors (Gretton especially) nevertheless provide us with many moments of wonderful dry humour, and there is no character who is less than fully real and alive. The only ones who seem to sense that they are playing out a potential tragedy are Curtis himself and Annik Honore - a Belgian woman whom he meets on tour and begins an affair with.

"I'm afraid," Annik says to Curtis, "afraid that I'll fall in love with you."

It's too late for that - for Annik and for us.



~

While not wanting to ruin the somberness of the film, I absolutely HAVE to share this picture with you of Sam Riley, and a thought that occupied my mind for an embarrassing amount of the film's playing time:

SIRIUS BLACK, circa 1979?! SRSLY.

Comments 
16th-Jun-2007 08:25 pm (UTC)
You, my dear, have just made my day. This review is wonderful and makes me anxious to see the it even more. I have mixed feelings about Curtis: part of me sees him as just an overly pretentious, asshole kid. On the other hand, his lyrics, obsessions, and circumstances make me believe and feel the tormented genius side. It appears this film finds the right balance between the two.

Incidentally, if you now find yourself a fan of Joy Division's music, I (and [info]decidedly too I should think) would be happy to help you out.
16th-Jun-2007 08:27 pm (UTC) - can't type
Er, see the film.
16th-Jun-2007 11:12 pm (UTC)
I think the film is ultimately very sympathetic to Curtis, but what I think what really sells it is how it doesn't force it: there is not a single overwrought moment, and Sam Riley plays like the man just is, like he acts without really thinking, and seems to be half in a daze most of the time.

There's a scene between Ian and Debbie where she's confronting him with knowledge about Annik, and the camera doesn't go in for any close ups on Ian; it just holds them both in frame, and even as you totally understand Debbie's anger, what stands out is how Ian is literally shrinking, backing into a wall, not saying a word. Throughout the movie, what you sense very acutely is his fragility, and Riley's physical appearance (much younger than Morton who plays Deborah, with spidery limbs, and huge heavy-lidded eyes) underscores that from the first scene, where he's just a young man in a long coat walking through a suburban street.

Even if you weren't a fan of JD, I would have said see it, because it is such a beautiful-looking film. There is a moment that comes close to being a little too precious in the second half, when Ian's voice-over (very sparingly used, and usually to very good effect) comes on, but otherwise I think the film does a great job of hinting, not telling.

And the concert scenes were fabulous. :)
17th-Jun-2007 02:42 pm (UTC)
All great things to read! Thanks.
17th-Jun-2007 01:33 pm (UTC)
I cannot wait to see this. My husband, who is pretty damn smart, bought me a Joy Division box set last year for a birthday (or was it anniversary ? Don't remember.) I love them so much it's ridiculous.

Thanks for a really thoughtful review- I was hoping someone I respected would say it was worth watching.
17th-Jun-2007 01:49 pm (UTC)
I just know you're going to love it. I was a bit reluctant at first about seeing it because it sounded so gloomy, but it's also the opposite o deadening - I came out of it feeling more attuned and sensitive to other people's feelings than I did going in. And at times the images were so painfully, starkly beautiful, I could have cried.

I think I might have to beg some of their music from the f-list one of these days.
This page was loaded Dec 30th 2009, 3:57 am GMT.